Do people really believe she cut his finger off?

It is such a wildly absurd claim. She would have to have thrown it at a certain angle at a particular speed and he would need to be perfectly still and even then, how would a full glass bottle thrown like that not bruise the finger? How would it crack on impact and magically cut off his finger at the same time? They believe something as tom and Jerry esque as that based on Depp saying it alone but not that he might have hit her ever?!