Who was a player you thought was going to be amazing but didn't pan out?

For me, I'll start with a trio of tight ends, Tony Moeak, James O'Shaughnessy and Jody Fortson.

Tony had the catch of the year his first game of the season (that was later surpassed by another team), but then he got injured and never seemed to recapture that magic.

James had some nice moves and catches and I thought we would have an awesome 1-2 punch with him and TK, but it never came about.

Jody made some amazing catches, but injuries seemed to keep him off the field mostly.