Best Honeymoon that feels exclusive and bougie but is a good bang for your buck

Hi all,

My fiancé and I are planning our honeymoon and looking for something that feels unique, bougie, or exclusive (like the Maldives/Seychelles) without the lengthy travel. Realistically we will only have about five nights to spend somewhere and we will travel from NYC. We’ve looked at some Mexico all inclusives that seem like good options, but Mexico feels a little bit basic. We will likely go in February, but possibly could go in early October. We were looking at Saint Martin, Aruba, Curaçao as options and would love recommendations, as well as any other locations. We love food and would love to be somewhere where we can get great meals- doesn’t have to be an all inclusive spot, our budget probably doesn’t exceed 7k, but still open to all suggestions!